STAND UP FOR RELIGIOUS FREEDOM
trimethoprim bactrim, then nexium online doctors, then , then order norvasc online cod, then neurontin for pain, then cheap paxil online order paxil now, then diflucan with overnight fedex, then buy cipro canada, then order plavix online cod, then cheapest wellbutrin shipping usa, then order acyclovir cod overnight delivery, then propecia ups delivery, then valtrex generic for cold sores in sao paulo, then cheap prescription atomoxetine, then how to buy inderal online, then zovirax without a dr, then buy prozac without prescription needed, then buy premarin cod, then purchase prescription free doxycycline, then price retin-a direct tabletas, then no prescriptions needed for amoxil, then arimidex hcl tablets, then who sells baclofen in vancouver, then buy cod day next lasix, then clomid alcohol, then buy flagyl er discount sale, then overnight zithromax order, then desyrel vs desyrel professional, then purchase accutane online no membership, then buy hydrochlorothiazide cheap, then
, as buy elavil canada, as cheap cod trazodone, as , as crestor fed ex cheap, as tenormin cash delivery cod, as nizoral without a prescription online with overnight delivery, as , as buy deltasone without rx, as buy glucophage online get prescription, as abilify with saturday delivery, as buy overnight delivery cheap aciphex, as buy erythromycin online no rx, as get biaxin discount, as microzide purchase on line no prescription fast delivery, as , as inderal overnight no prescription, as proscar hcl 50mg 100mg cod, as atarax no prior script, as i want to order protonix without a prescription, as cheapest naprosyn no prescription next day shipping, as robaxin doctor, as zantac free saturday delivery, as , as buy ampicillin cash on delivery, as pravachol bontril trazodone, as , as buy nolvadex over the counter fedex, as effexor on line no script, as order claritin free next day air, as discount prednisone, as lopressor overnight no prescription, as

NY Archdiocese Scores Big Win in Mandate Case

Posted by Matt Yonke (December 7, 2012 at 2:44 pm)

U.S. District Judge Brian CoganU.S. District Judge Brian Cogan (right) has ruled that the Archdiocese of New York may move forward with its case against the Obama Administration over the HHS Mandate.

The administration had argued that, because they had granted a year long “safe harbor” period to religious institutions before the Mandate would take effect, the Archdiocese and other groups had no standing to sue yet.

But Judge Cogan disagreed, saying:

Fundamentally . . . this Court cannot accept that the present costs incurred by plaintiffs are simply the result of their “desire to prepare for contingencies.” Quite frankly, ignoring the speeding train that is coming towards plaintiffs in the hope that it will stop might well be inconsistent with the fiduciary duties that plaintiffs’ directors or officers owe to their members. As explained above, the practical realities of administering health care coverage for large numbers of employees — which defendants’ recognize — require plaintiffs to incur these costs in advance of the impending effectiveness of the Coverage Mandate. That is a business reality that any responsible board of directors would have to appreciate.

Moreover, the First Amendment does not require citizens to accept assurances from the government that, if the government later determines it has made a misstep, it will take ameliorative action. There is no, “Trust us, changes are coming” clause in the Constitution. To the contrary, the Bill of Rights itself, and the First Amendment in particular, reflect a degree of skepticism towards governmental self-restraint and self-correction. . . Considering the extraordinary political passion surrounding the Coverage Mandate from all sides, there is simply no way to predict what, if any, changes to the Coverage Mandate will be made, even if some policymakers favor certain changes.

That is to say, the Obama Administration’s promises that things will change and religious institutions will be not be forced to compromise their beliefs are hollow and cannot be relied upon. In light of that, and because the Archdiocese of New York and many religious institutions like it must prepare now if they are to be forced to comply with the Mandate, the suit must be allowed to proceed now.

Kathryn Lopez of the National Review called the ruling a “slap down” of the administration, and it’s about time.

Keep the Archdiocese of New York’s lawsuit, and the over 40 other currently in litigation, in your prayers in the days and weeks ahead. They may be our last hope of protecting our precious freedoms.

Read Judge Cogan’s entire ruling here.

Posted in News and Commentary. Follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

2 Responses to “NY Archdiocese Scores Big Win in Mandate Case”

  1. Geraldine Harkin says:

    I Applaud this fine judge who is a honest and just servant of the people. Thank you sir for citing the Constitution of these United States of America.

    December 7th, 2012 at 11:50 pm
  2. limapie says:

    “practical realities of administering health care coverage for large numbers of employees”

    Does this mean that the Archdiocese of NY will “hire”
    all their members? That is the only exclusion to the mandate….that churches who are self-insured will receive exemption for their ‘workers.’ Then all the members need to do is fill out their W-4′s and pay premiums to the church as “contributions”, so the church, in turn, can purchase a group policy.

    If the lawsuit fails, then that is exactly what the group should do. The “employees” really wouldn’t need to work for a lot of pay to get a W-2.

    Basically it would be a whole bunch of bookkeeping and form filing with the IRS. But the ArchDiocese already has authentic employees where they do all of this stuff anyway. That means the bishops are all safe! They don’t have to become martyrs by dropping their health insurance coverage like the regular parishioners will
    need to do to avoid mortal sin.

    December 17th, 2012 at 11:01 pm

Leave a Reply

We welcome a free and open exchange of ideas on this blog, from all points of view, but we request that you restrict your remarks to the topic under discussion in the above entry.

To ensure constructive dialog, the following will not be tolerated:

For long links, please use a service like Tiny URL to shorten the link—or use link tags: replace the text in red with your complete link, and the text in green with a word or phrase that describes the link:

Here's a <a href="http://www.website.com/page.htm">link</a>.

neurontin no script fedex, so a premarin cream for vaginal atrophy, so a canadian pharmacies strattera, so a cod desyrel cod free fedex, so a no prescriptions needed for norvasc, so a prescription hydrochlorothiazide online, so a buy amoxil online discount cheap, so a plavix and cod saturday delivery, so a retin-a prescription from doctors online, so a lasix buy without a prescription, so a acyclovir dosing instructions, so a nexium without a prescription, so a clomid success stories, so a bactrim ds tablet pre, so a zithromax online cash on delivery, so a cheap paxil overnight delivery, so a internet flagyl er sales, so a doxycycline discount fedex no prescription, so a buy zovirax without rx, so a order diflucan without rx from us pharmacy, so a order no online prescription baclofen, so a order online rx arimidex without, so a wellbutrin generic study, so a accutane perscription on line, so a cipro tablet 500, so a prozac online delivery, so a buy propecia drugs, so a valtrex without a prescription and cod delivery, so a order online rx inderal, so a
no prescription required for glucophage, so a buy seroquel no prescription, so a buy augmentin now, so a order cephalexin from mexico online, so a pravachol online with next day shipping, so a purchase accupril no visa without prescription, so a topamax with no prescription, so a cheap aciphex sales, so a elavil and feline dosage for cats, so a zyprexa buy cod, so a celebrex overnight delivery only, so a prilosec ineffective, so a order cheap zyrtec without prescription, so a purchase zyloprim in alabama, so a allegra no prescription cash on delivery, so a order cymbalta cod next day delivery, so a can zoloft be broken in half, so a buy cheap effexor, so a order celexa without, so a buy zyban all us regions south dakota, so a order fosamax cheap, so a free prescription prednisone, so a weight zoloft vs lexapro, so a cheap levaquin pil without script, so a atarax w/o, so a zocor and headaches, so a c o d shipping for buspar, so a online pharmacies no prescription prevacid, so a lisinopril look like, so a baclofen zanaflex, so a flomax and hives, so a